patching...
Update: Get Patch in your inbox every morning. Sign up for our free daily newsletter! »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

LETTER: Town Meeting 'Got It Right'

Arlington resident A. Michael Ruderman, a Precinct 9 Town Meeting Member, writes that residents should vote to uphold Town Meeting's regulation of gas-powered leaf blowers at the Special Election on Thursday, July 19.

 

The following is a Letter to the Editor from Arlington resident A. Michael Ruderman, a Precinct 9 Town Meeting Member.

In the July 19 Special Election, I urge you to maintain the regulation of gas-powered leaf blowers that we passed in our Annual Town Meeting.

We heard many arguments in town meeting against leaf blowers: their noise, their engines’ pollution, their blasting of sand and grit into neighbors’ homes. Yet, we were mindful of these tools’ speed and ease in corralling broad expanses of leaves in the fall. So, we amended the original proposal and approved a compromise: no gas-powered blowers on private property, during the driest weeks of the year, when the fewest leaves are on the ground, and the most windows and porches are open to fresh air.

It is during these weeks I most often see leaf-blowers employed as driveway and parking lot “sweepers.” For my neighbors in Precinct 9 who live beside businesses’ parking, the blower noise, reflected from the asphalt, is a frequent disturbance throughout spring and summer. Crews have many options for cleaning up this hardscape, options that actually collect debris instead of blasting it onto someone else's property. There are the quiet and efficient sweeping vehicles that towns use on streets and parking lots. At the opposite end of the mechanization scale, there is the ultimate in “green” and quiet sweepers for driveway-size applications: push brooms.

The compromise we passed--again, not a ban, but a regulation--requires us to do a little better at keeping the peace and quiet of a civil community.  I think Town Meeting “got it right,” as we always try to do, when there are many sides and strong emotions on a particular subject. Please vote to uphold this regulation on July 19.

A. Michael Ruderman
9 Alton St.
Town Meeting Member, Precinct 9

 

Have an opinion on the special election? You can submit a “Letter to the Editor” to Arlington Patch Editor John Waller at john.waller@patch.com (be sure to include your full name and address, and please explicitly state that your email is intended as a “Letter to the Editor”)

About this column: Submit Letters to the Editor as blog posts or by emailing Arlington Patch Editor John Waller at john.waller@patch.com. Please include your full name and the name of the street you live on. Related Topics: A. Michael Ruderman, Government, Leaf-Blower Ban, Letters To The Editor, Special Election, and Town Meeting

Tim

12:49 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012

Hi A . Michael , I think town meeting got it all wrong . See who are you or any town town meeting member to tell me a grown up " Real Townie " home owner and tax payer what I can and cannot do on my property? YOU DON'T .. My suggestion to you if you do not like the noise here in Arlington there are plenty of other places to live ..
Move away ...I hear Vermont is quiet

Reply
Comment_arrow

inthegloaming

2:33 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012

What a neighborly response! Especially from a "grown up" whining "You can't make me!" My mother taught me that it was inconsiderate, low class and uncouth to disturb my neighbors. That I didn't own the block. Being a "real townie" doesn't confer ownership on you either. What did YOUR mom teach you about manners?

Comment_arrow

charles ginsberg

11:56 am on Thursday, July 19, 2012

Tim I suggest you move to kenmore square where you can have all the noise you want plus

Tim

11:27 am on Sunday, July 15, 2012

My mother taught me you can't have your way all the time . There are lots of things my neighbors do that disturb me but that's life . I have the option to move . Who do these elite people think they are ? What's next ? Lawn mowers , snow blowers , snow plows ? First off if this isn't repealed this week , I will be filing an appeal with the Attny General because the original vote at town meeting was flawed . Moderator Leone had people so confused I don't
think he even knew what he was voting on . I have the
video and it don't lie . He was so confused he even swore
in the middle of it . Second the way the home rule was
written was incorrect . The dpw will be allowed to use Leaf blowers and the tax payers can't .. I DON'T THINK SO ...I will personally file the lawsuit and the injunction against the town . It' won't be the first time I have sued the town and it won't be the last ... Happy leaf blowing ...

blowers but the tax payers can't . Good luck trying to

Reply
Comment_arrow

charles ginsberg

2:00 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

tim is going to PERSONALLY file a lawsuit against the town and try and get an injunction. sounds like a possible reality television show in the making. tim, please I am dying to know, what did you sue the town over before?

inthegloaming

6:57 pm on Tuesday, July 17, 2012

But it seems she didn't teachYOU that YOU can't have your way all the time. "Timmy, dear, stop being such a sore loser. It's embarrassing. Love, Mom."

I don't have a horse in this race. I've not been bothered by blowers, so the vote either way doesn't affect me one wy or the other. But since it has bothered others, their needs count more than those of us who aren't. That's caled being a good neighbor. Oh, and the law stipulates something that sounds like "the peaceful enjoyment" of one's property.

Reply

Andrew W.

10:28 am on Thursday, July 19, 2012

Re Tim: the distinction is that the effect of leaf blowers isn't limited to one's property.

An analogy would be loud music: eventually at some volume, the right to play loud music on your property butts up against a neighbor's right to not have loud music on their property.

The positions taken for and against leaf blowers are essentially two sides of the same coin: the way local government should balance the old struggle between "freedom to" and "freedom from". The compromise struck at the Town Meeting was messy but, I think, reasonable.

Reply

Paul

11:45 am on Thursday, July 19, 2012

I agree with Tim in that government cannot protect everyone from everything at all times. There are myriad daily noises from starting one's car early in the morning to go to work, to dump trucks backing up "beeping" etc. A leaf blower is used to clean up and maintain property, a POSITIVE. I've never had a situation on my street when some guy used his leaf blower for HOURS just to disturb me or a neighbor who wants the silence of a convent all the time. If the Town bans leaf blowers for residents, it should NOT allow town employees to use leaf blowers: SIMPLE COMMON SENSE. i don't get some of the people on here who made childish, peevish comments. Laws and codes are for all residents of the town.... just because some guy lives in a fourth floor apartment on Mass ave in East Arlington and doesn't need a leaf blower (but probably needs a life), doesn't make his input any more or less equal to a guy in Morningside with two acres. It is time for our Town politicians to get OUT of our lives. Tim: GO FOR IT. Others in Arlington will support you.

Reply
Comment_arrow

charles ginsberg

12:00 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

We heard many arguments in town meeting against leaf blowers: their noise, their engines’ pollution, their blasting of sand and grit into neighbors’ homes. Yet, we were mindful of these tools’ speed and ease in corralling broad expanses of leaves in the fall. So, we amended the original proposal and approved a compromise: no gas-powered blowers on private property, during the driest weeks of the year, when the fewest leaves are on the ground, and the most windows and porches are open to fresh air.

Rich

11:50 am on Thursday, July 19, 2012

Check out what the press is saying! Arlington is a laughingstock right now!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FplRnEGO2lc&feature=plcp

Reply
Comment_arrow

inthegloaming

12:13 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

He made some good points about the issue. I'm glad I'm not voting, it's a tough one.

(On a more positive note: don't worry too much what Fox News thinks of Arlington. They're the ones who are usually the laughing stock.)

Comment_arrow

charles ginsberg

2:19 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

If fox news is laughing at arlington then I know we got it right.

charles ginsberg

11:54 am on Thursday, July 19, 2012

I'm with you michael. you said it all. I'll be voting YES

Reply

Paul

11:55 am on Thursday, July 19, 2012

Hey RICH, thanks that was AWESOME! I hadn't caught that before. RIGHT ON! Everyone in town GO OUT AND VOTE this cocamamie idea DOWN! The editors at the Advocate look like complete dorks today..... like the guy on the Fox News said... they are AFRAID that DEMOCRACY might work.

Reply

John R. Pitingolo

2:59 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

I grew up in Arlington and still have family there. This vote, if anything, should be about this revealing quote... "Our major objection to overturning the regulation, however, is that it could establish a 'harmful precedent' that decisions by town meetings could be seen as subject for reversal via petition initiated ballot initiatives." Aside from being a perfect example of elitist liberal "reasoning" (which by the way, could and should be used nationwide to educate Americans as to the threat we are up against), the Arlington selectman who wrote this needs to be slapped upside the head with a rolled up copy of the United States Constitution.
Regards and Good Luck Arlington

Reply
Comment_arrow

Dennis

11:56 am on Saturday, July 21, 2012

John. - this is a shining example of how national politics has ruined our ability to work out issues at a local level. All people do now is try to figure out the political camp of their neighbors in town government. Once they conclude they're from the "other side" then they know how to vote. They can stop thinking. It's lazy and not how towns have worked thongs out for 200 years.

Drew

4:50 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

Just one basic question to all the anti- gas blowers that nobody seems to be acknowledging. What do you plan to do about all the hundreds of people like me who fully intend to use our ELECTRIC blowers anytime we want? Call the police and report me, Charles? Why? I'm not breaking the law. So all this is basically moot and except for the questionable air quality improvement, it just adds fodder to today's Ch 5 news where Arlington, once more, is being depicted as the laughing stock of New England because of this new law.

Reply
Comment_arrow

charles ginsberg

8:12 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012

electric is fine. i have an electric lawn mower and it is 10 times quieter than the same size gas model. the electric leaf bloweres are much cleaner and quieter than the gas ones. so go and blow till your heart's content.

James

1:03 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

I agree 100% with this letter. It's a nice compromise. It's too bad some people can't help but view the partial-year leaf blower ban as some kind of ASSAULT ON THE VERY FABRIC OF OUR LIBERTY AND FREEDOM!!!!!

They've had this type of ban in place in Cambridge for years and it has worked out fine.

Leaf Blowers are for BLOWING LEAVES. And there aren't any of those to blow during the time the ban is in effect. When the Fall rolls around... bust 'em out and use them for what they are intended for.

Reply
Comment_arrow

GWGW

5:33 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

Your only making the problem worse = .....people will use GAS mowers revved on hi to blow leaves.......havent thought it through....have you? Liberals never do.....and yet they think they are so smart .....its funny

Paul

1:11 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

to Jimmie Brooks: Arlington IS NOT Cambridge. If you want to live in a Liberal Stepford Community.... go live in Cambridge. Chelsea has a lot of drugs...maybe with your input Arlington can reach for that environment, too. It IS about too much government involvement at EVERY level.

Reply
Comment_arrow

James

1:30 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

"If you want to live in a Liberal Stepford Community.... go live in Cambridge"

How about this... if you want to live in a Fox News stronghold... go live in Alabama

Comment_arrow

inthegloaming

4:53 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

Government? Oh, you mean the residents of Arlington exercising their civic level rights and actually voting for the ban, based on practical, fact-filled arguments on why the gas powered (not electric powered) types are a harmful nuisance? That "government"?

Wogga

1:18 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

but it used to be Cambridge...

Reply
Comment_arrow

Paul

1:35 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

Wigger : there obviously was a reason that the town fathers decided to break away from Cambridge.

Paul

1:34 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

I vacation there and love it. Great radio and T.V. reception for FOX News al over the State, too. LOL

Reply
Comment_arrow

James

1:39 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

great... so it's settled. need help packing?

charles ginsberg

2:04 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

james and I will both help u pack. and I'll toss in a box of kleenex.

Reply

GWGW

5:32 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012

Your only screwing yourself.....people will use GAS mowers revved on hi to blow leaves.......havent thought it through....have you? Liberals never do.....and yet they think they are so smart .....its funny

Reply

Dennis

11:49 am on Saturday, July 21, 2012

You are correct - this was not thought through...by all parties. We didnt used to have this problem because there were no leaf blowers 30 years ago. Now 6 show up to blow away grass clippings. It's overdone. How about a noise and power limit on blowers? Or a limit to the number of blowers in operation at the same time?

This is not over.

Reply

charles ginsberg

3:20 pm on Saturday, July 21, 2012

All construction in Arlington including leaf blowers is allowed to start at 7 in the morning. I have 3 neighbors who all use different landscapers. each one of them has 3 or 4 leafblowers and most times they start at 7 a.m.
nice way to wake up 3 days per week . if the ordinace had said even 8 or 9 a.m. I would have been ok with that. BUT it was probably impossible just to include leaf blowers as the only tool not to be used before 8 or 9. I don't know. So I am happy with the outcome. Besides, this regulation does not ban gas blowers per say but only for 4 months a year when there are practically no leaves on the ground anyway. And, oh yes, this is over.

Reply

Dennis

3:34 pm on Saturday, July 21, 2012

You are making my point. All these little details matter. Time to start, hours of operation, DB level, etc. What is it we really want from this? Most people would settle for "reasonable usage". And from all the comments it sounds to me like people are actually starting to think about what constitutes "reasonable" usage.

So you see, this is not over. Especially since it only takes 300 signatures to call a special Town Meeting. And I'm willing to bet it will not pass this time , at least in its current form. And that may be a good thing.

Reply

Leave a comment